Other Commentary

A rising sun sets

2009-09-03Asia Times

BEIJING - The landslide victory on Sunday of the Democratic Party of Japan (DPJ) over the Liberal Democratic Party (LDP) - which has ruled Japan almost without interruption for the past six decades - is the latest signal of a momentous transformation in Asia.

The past many decades, marked by Japan's political primacy and power in the area, have really ended; and the more distant past, signified by China's regional dominance, has returned.

In a way, history is repeating itself. Taro Aso, the LDP's outgoing premier, who was crushingly defeated in Sunday's vote, is the great-great-grandson of Toshimichi Okubo, one of the three men who led the Meiji Reformation in the mid-1800s and who is widely regarded as a founding father of modern Japan. That era has come to a close, and something else is about to start in Japan and Asia - exactly a month before neighboring China proclaims a new beginning.

On October 1, Beijing celebrates the 60th anniversary of the founding of the People's Republic of China. Sixty years is a celestial cycle in the Chinese horoscope (12 signs per five elements), a fitting moment for President Hu Jintao to sit at the Tiananmen rostrum and, as chairman Mao Zedong once proclaimed that China had stood up, say that China is now walking, perhaps even running.

For about 150 years, Japan could claim it was the best Asian student of Western powers. It beat waning China in the 1880s, taking over Korea and Taiwan; it crushed fading Russia in 1905, gaining a foothold in Manchuria; it chose the right side in World War I, helping to expel the Germans from the Far East. All these successes whet its appetite, went to its head, and made Japan think it could push all the white men out of Asia, replace the Western colonies with its own rule, and even conquer the once-mighty China.

It turned into a bad dream. Still, not even defeat in World War II managed to stop the student, which set out to emulate and outperform its American teacher. Japan was eventually stopped in the late 1980s, when America won on two fronts - against Tokyo's technological and financial threats and against the Soviet Union, which after seven decades crumbled.

It was a sudden halt for Japan, but at the time it seemed temporary. Japan looked poised to come back in one way or another. In 1989, the Soviet Union also seemed ready to turn a new leaf and begin again, when it let all the Eastern European countries slip out of its grip and enter the West's fold. China, conversely, with the Tiananmen crackdown in 1989, seemed to have turned back the clock and appeared set to become once more the sick man of Asia.

Everything turned out differently. Twenty years later, the relative position of these countries is totally different: In a year or two, China should become the first economy of Asia in a century to overtake Japan's gross domestic product (GDP).

In the meantime, Japan's decline has become more than simple statistics. The social contract that guaranteed lifetime jobs, family values and security is falling apart. Japanese papers report of elderly people who let themselves die at home, without family or friends to take care of them and without a pension to live on. Other elderly people resort to petty theft to increase their meager purchasing power.

Young people aren't faring much better. Many have abandoned hopes for one of the few safe sources of lifetime employment, and they practice job-hopping as if it were a hobby. Unlike their parents, they are not driven and dedicated to their companies - yet why should they be? Japan is still quite well off, and they can still afford a decent life - but there is no big dream or ambition to fight for when opportunities are fewer.

The economy is in very bad shape. In the last trimester, GDP grew by 0.9%, but unemployment in July was up to a record high of 5.7%. The public sector's on-balance-sheet debt is expected to top 200% in 2010. In theory, the situation is not too bad, as Japan is a net creditor (it is one of the largest purchasers of America's bonds), and all its internal debt is sold to Japanese people, so the risk is low and interest on this internal debt is not high.

A radical policy of privatizing state assets and bad state companies could offset this debt. But those assets de facto are under the control of the powerful bureaucracy, which together with the LDP and large companies formed the three sides of Japan's post-war triangle of power and which made the "miracle" possible. Now, the LDP has collapsed, and the DPJ promises to trim the powers of the bureaucracy. Japan, then, will need a new political pact of power, and it is unclear who, aside from the DPJ, will shape it.

Externally, Japan has been export-driven, centered on the US and Europe. Yet in recent months, China has become its largest trading partner, signaling also a shift of objective importance for the country.

On the strategic front, Japan faces dramatic changes. For decades it was America's stalwart in Asia, enjoying privileged access to Washington. Now, with China's rise, it might have to play second fiddle to this new bilateral relationship. To position itself better for new regional politics and new market drives, the DPJ has pledged to form better ties with neighboring Asian countries, and China will be the foremost.

In other words, both on the political and the economic fronts, a Japan looking for a new future could favor the new tone in US-China ties. It is unlikely to hinder them as it could gain from both sides of the Pacific.

The time is right. Sixty years ago, the foundation of the People's Republic of China decided Japan's destiny in Asia. America lost China, its old ally was reduced to Taiwan, and it needed to rebuild a strong Japan to counter the strategic threat of Mao. Now that Mao's shadow is fading, and China's economy looks like the possible locomotive of future growth and an exit from the global financial crisis, Japan could emerge not as the Asian alternative to China, but a bridge - some kind of glue or guarantor - between the US and China.

Economically, a switch in trade signals this. Culturally, it has already happened. Many modern Chinese words, like democracy and science, have been imported from the Japanese, who had previously used Chinese characters to coin new concepts.

Moreover, the players in this new political and economic scene have no interest in expelling the US from the Asian scene; they all know that in the foreseeable future, the US is a guarantor of regional peace, as it promises security to Japan and South Korea and thus prevents an arms race in the region [1].

All these theoretical ideas need practical solutions, and this won't be easy. Japan's premier-designate Yukio Hatoyama promises nothing short of a massive reformation, possibly as big as the Meiji Reformation some 150 years ago. Hatoyama's blue-blood lineage, his willingness to face Japan's many difficulties, and the DPJ's massive popular mandate could be a sound platform to make this work. However, old Japan and old interests might still want to fight to buy themselves another day.

Asia has about a year to see whether or not the DPJ can act on its promises and change Japan. Next year, there will be a vote for the Upper House and Hatoyama needs to gain an absolute majority there. If he fails, and fails to convince voters of his determination to change, the old LDP might return - and then hopes for change might fade as China steams ahead in the region and in the world.

Note
1. See The blessing of China's threat (http://www.lastampa.it/_web/cmstp/tmplrubriche/giornalisti/grubrica.asp?ID_blog=98&ID_articolo=9&ID_sezione=180&sezione=) La Stampa, June 4, 2007. See also A new future for the history of Japan in Asia (http://www.lastampa.it/_web/cmstp/tmplrubriche/giornalisti/grubrica.asp?ID_blog=98&ID_articolo=34&ID_sezione=437&sezione=) La Stampa, August 7, 2007. (2009-09-03 Asia Times)

Focus

+MoreOther Commentary